[FranticFatality]

Now, I will firstly add that I apologize if this has been covered before. I really do. I could not find ANYTHING in the search. So don't eat me up.

So anyway...

Imagine if a protagonist got into a fight with another. Who would suck the most? Like, who can't beat the sh*t out of everyone? Not at once, just like, who would suck at fighting every single other protagonist at once?

I would say CJ and Toni.

Edit - I messed up the poll. Sorry, wait a sec while I add a new one

[universetwisters]

Oh goodness, so many choices!

[ClaudeSpeedRulez]

I'm lol'ing hard.

[Mainland Marauder]

OK, it's fixed.

[FranticFatality]

QUOTE (Mainland Marauder @ Friday, Aug 10 2012, 00:35)

OK, it's fixed.

Thanks

[redx165]

QUOTE (FranticFatality @ Thursday, Aug 9 2012, 23:52)

Now, I will firstly add that I apologize if this has been covered before. I really do. I could not find ANYTHING in the search. So don't eat me up. So anyway... Imagine if a protagonist got into a fight with another. Who would suck the most? Like, who can't beat the sh*t out of everyone? Not at once, just like, who would suck at fighting every single other protagonist at once? I would say CJ and Toni. Edit - I messed up the poll. Sorry, wait a sec while I add a new one

I say anyone in the IV era. The fighting system was the worst in this era.

[StoneHead37]

QUOTE (redx165 @ Thursday, Aug 9 2012, 20:03)

QUOTE (FranticFatality @ Thursday, Aug 9 2012, 23:52) Now, I will firstly add that I apologize if this has been covered before. I really do. I could not find ANYTHING in the search. So don't eat me up. So anyway... Imagine if a protagonist got into a fight with another. Who would suck the most? Like, who can't beat the sh*t out of everyone? Not at once, just like, who would suck at fighting every single other protagonist at once? I would say CJ and Toni. Edit - I messed up the poll. Sorry, wait a sec while I add a new one  I say anyone in the IV era. The fighting system was the worst in this era.

I'd beg to differ. Niko probably is the best unarmed fighter in the series. His strong hooks and push off kicks can do a lot of damage, in addition to that killer counter of his that can drain half an enemies health.

[redx165]

QUOTE (StoneHead37 @ Friday, Aug 10 2012, 01:07)

QUOTE (redx165 @ Thursday, Aug 9 2012, 20:03) QUOTE (FranticFatality @ Thursday, Aug 9 2012, 23:52) Now, I will firstly add that I apologize if this has been covered before. I really do. I could not find ANYTHING in the search. So don't eat me up. So anyway... Imagine if a protagonist got into a fight with another. Who would suck the most? Like, who can't beat the sh*t out of everyone? Not at once, just like, who would suck at fighting every single other protagonist at once? I would say CJ and Toni. Edit - I messed up the poll. Sorry, wait a sec while I add a new one  I say anyone in the IV era. The fighting system was the worst in this era. I'd beg to differ. Niko probably is the best unarmed fighter in the series. His strong hooks and push off kicks can do a lot of damage, in addition to that killer counter of his that can drain half an enemies health.

The fight system was the worst. In SA you could learn more moves and become better. But the fighting system is to slow in IV. I'm hoping it's better and better controls.

[StoneHead37]

QUOTE (redx165 @ Thursday, Aug 9 2012, 20:32)

QUOTE (StoneHead37 @ Friday, Aug 10 2012, 01:07) QUOTE (redx165 @ Thursday, Aug 9 2012, 20:03) QUOTE (FranticFatality @ Thursday, Aug 9 2012, 23:52) Now, I will firstly add that I apologize if this has been covered before. I really do. I could not find ANYTHING in the search. So don't eat me up. So anyway... Imagine if a protagonist got into a fight with another. Who would suck the most? Like, who can't beat the sh*t out of everyone? Not at once, just like, who would suck at fighting every single other protagonist at once? I would say CJ and Toni. Edit - I messed up the poll. Sorry, wait a sec while I add a new one  I say anyone in the IV era. The fighting system was the worst in this era. I'd beg to differ. Niko probably is the best unarmed fighter in the series. His strong hooks and push off kicks can do a lot of damage, in addition to that killer counter of his that can drain half an enemies health. The fight system was the worst. In SA you could learn more moves and become better. But the fighting system is to slow in IV. I'm hoping it's better and better controls.

I see what you mean. You're right when you say SA was more in depth with learning new fighting techniques. That should be carried over into V for sure. Picking what kind of unarmed opponent you are would be nice.

[Senex Iunior]

In a melee fight, Klebitz because of his limp.

[Miamivicecity]

Niko's punches are brutal. He's also deadly with a knife.

I'd say the worst would be default CJ. He hits like a limp dick teenager with self esteem issues.

[lzw3]

QUOTE (Miamivicecity @ Friday, Aug 10 2012, 15:19)

I'd say the worst would be default CJ. He hits like a limp dick teenager with self esteem issues.

But I would think he could beat any of the gta 3 era portags. Wasn't he the only one that could punch while running. The rest, from what I thought, have to stop to punch.

[Miamivicecity]

QUOTE (lzw3 @ Friday, Aug 10 2012, 16:50)

QUOTE (Miamivicecity @ Friday, Aug 10 2012, 15:19) I'd say the worst would be default CJ. He hits like a limp dick teenager with self esteem issues. But I would think he could beat any of the gta 3 era portags. Wasn't he the only one that could punch while running. The rest, from what I thought, have to stop to punch.

Nah. Claude and Tommy can also.

[lzw3]

QUOTE (Miamivicecity @ Friday, Aug 10 2012, 16:01)

QUOTE (lzw3 @ Friday, Aug 10 2012, 16:50) QUOTE (Miamivicecity @ Friday, Aug 10 2012, 15:19) I'd say the worst would be default CJ. He hits like a limp dick teenager with self esteem issues. But I would think he could beat any of the gta 3 era portags. Wasn't he the only one that could punch while running. The rest, from what I thought, have to stop to punch. Nah. Claude and Tommy can also.

Claude can't can he?! I know that he definitely can't on PS2 but maybe you have it on PC.

[Miamivicecity]

Haha whoops you're right. Tommy definitely does.

[BabeRuth]

QUOTE (Miamivicecity @ Friday, Aug 10 2012, 05:19)

CJ. He hits like he is a strong ass motherf@#%er, while Niko has low self esteem issues.

Fixed

Niko had the worst fighting moves.

[Miamivicecity]

lol.

Gotta love our (friendly) SA/GTA IV rivalry. You know I'm right though.

[BabeRuth]

I'm glad you find that fuuny

You have the knowledge and wisdom to be right about alot of things, Miamivicecity.

Thing is....i'll flame IV & VC everytime you flame SA just a little heads up.

[Miamivicecity]

QUOTE (BabeRuth @ Friday, Aug 10 2012, 18:08)

I'm glad you find that fuuny You have the knowledge and wisdom to be right about alot of things, Miamivicecity. Thing is....i'll flame IV & VC everytime you flame SA just a little heads up.

Just a bit of tongue & cheek humour.

[dragon_goran_mijo]

If we're going by default? CJ would get raped in the first round. Lack of size and defense moves are bad. Vic would come in second, and most likely Luis would come 3rd because of the fight ring.