this matchup sucks
I love both of these movies but they're SO different.
I'm gonna' have to take the line of thought offered by TheCacti.
There Will Be Blood is a fantastic film, no doubt, in virtually every aspect.
but there's something about Dead Poets Society that is indispensable. if I was stranded on a desert island and could only take one of these 2 pictures with me, it would have to be Dead Poets. TWBB is a quality film all the way around but it's also cold and has a very sad ending
Dead Poets is a thought-provoking, funny, and inspiring story that never gets tired.
the vote is for Dead Poets Society.