If you're going to start a whole new topic, you really must put far more effort into it. Explain properly what you mean. What are YOUR views? Why do you think it was or wasn't a 'good decision'?
If you want to start a debate, do it properly.
One of the worst things you can do in an opening post is to just pose a subject or question in so few words and more or less order us to discuss it for you. It comes across as ignorant, thoughtless and rude, which I'm sure wasn't your intention.