[Th3MaN1]

QUOTE (alifjenius @ Monday, Nov 28 2011, 17:41)

I think CJ will beat them all with his muscles. We couldn't upgrade characters' muscles except for him !

Correct me if I'm wrong,but I thought this is a fight between protagonists,not games.

[alifjenius]

QUOTE (Th3MaN1 @ Tuesday, Nov 29 2011, 02:02)

Correct me if I'm wrong,but I thought this is a fight between protagonists,not games.

Oh, okay then. If I have to edit the post, still it will goes to CJ. I don't know which fight we are talking about, if it's a fist fight, then CJ will win the fight (IMO, I don't know why I think it like this). But if it's about a gunfight, maybe Niko who already had past Army experience will win the fight

[Th3MaN1]

QUOTE (alifjenius @ Tuesday, Nov 29 2011, 01:14)

QUOTE (Th3MaN1 @ Tuesday, Nov 29 2011, 02:02) Correct me if I'm wrong,but I thought this is a fight between protagonists,not games. Oh, okay then. If I have to edit the post, still it will goes to CJ. I don't know which fight we are talking about, if it's a fist fight, then CJ will win the fight (IMO, I don't know why I think it like this). But if it's about a gunfight, maybe Niko who already had past Army experience will win the fight

Don't have to edit your post.It's your opinion,just saying that a lot of people here said CJ would win because he can learn fighting moves and work out,but it's the game that allows that,not the character.And btw,where did Vic break a neck?

[Ledsbourne]

I'd go with Tommy - he was in jail for 15 years for manslaughter and seems to be most decisive and strong character, he builds his own empire, has no problems killing his former bosses and friends who try to betray him and generally has the biggest balls of them all.

Second would be Claude - he's silent, but also doesn't have problems with killing anyone who gets on his way.

Now CJ - even tho I like GTA:SA more than 3 and VC, CJ is a pussy compared to the other 2 He let's a couple of corrupt cops threat him like their bitch and his timid behaviour leads to clean Tenpenny of all accusations (yeah, he can't kill 3 corrupt cops, but when he has a wanted level, he can shoot FBI agents and destroy police helicopters), he let's Catalina wear pants in their relationship, he begs Toreno for his life like a pansy, does jobs for Salvatore only 2 save a couple of losers, takes all the GSF back himself but still lets Sweet threat him like he's the boss, instead of just shooting Big Smoke, leaves him enough time to actually put a gunfight...

As for Niko, I only played a little GTA IV so he's without comparison here.

[acmilano]

CJ,he could learn 3 different martial-arts styles,have acess to best weapons from these 4,and he got strongest organisation behind him with connections with Triads,Astecas and government. Tommy got organisation but they are limited in Vice City only While Niko and Claude are just freelancers,Niko could call his few friends for a help while Claude dont have nobody.

[oglevempire]

Carl Johnson will never win a fight, he's a pussy, to be honest.
I liked his character, but he's just a small-time gang banger, who became somewhat rich with the time. He wouldn't win the fight.
Same goes to Tommy, he's a small-time mafia guy who then became big-time. I bet that his current life, truly ruined his fighting skills. It's more than obvious that he's not fighting these days. In theory, of course.
On the other hand, Niko, is a well-build army solider, whose life was always dedicated to crime and action. He fights a lot, he's got experience, he'll win the fight, of course.

[BabeRuth]

QUOTE (!!GameCH33TA!! @ Friday, Dec 26 2008, 10:00)

QUOTE (TheGreatWhiteDope @ Dec 26 2008, 17:23) Tommy was sent to prison for homicide and is an all-out badass. Wtf? All the people in the poll have commited homicide, only Tommy was stupid enough to be caught and go to prison, so that gives him a

I thought that was Claude.?

[shindogg]

i would say "anything goes" because any character is only as tough as the player controllin him but that wasnt an option. but i went with cj as i like his wide array of different fight moves. the only thing that would be cooler would be he could use them all at once, along with havin all weapons in game at once instead of that stupid weapon slot crap they put in there. i didnt play vice believe it or not, but im guessin its like III if it had the ability to fly helicopters and drive motorcycles as you cant swim, eat or change your clothes or even change your fight moves like you can with SA. i dont know if VC used that weapon slot crap or was like III where you can have everything. i miss bein able to have the flamethrower & grenade launcher at the same time! in any other game out there you could have a sword & a bat & a knife at the same time and set up buttons to switch with maybe. i know its off-topic (sorry) but if someone married the concepts of postal 2 with the concepts of SA, damn that would be kickass game of the century IMHO! well, i had found a way to change claude's fight style so he could do more moves when he punches or kicks in some game file (mightve been melee.dat but i forget as i havent played it in years because it would freeze sometimes & there wasnt a program like gta_sa-killer where you could just quit to windows instead of havin to reboot the computer & end up losin all unsaved documents) but it cant be done in-game so it doesnt really count. niko fights good but is somewhat slower than carl & claude, & claude has like just a kick & punch as default moves so hes the weakest. well, unless tommy has more than those 2 moves, hes just as pathetic as claude to me. i would play vice if it doesnt have weapon slots & you can change clothes. btw i think its weird that niko cant dive underwater in IV.

[Miamivicecity]

Niko because while the others are beating eachother senseless he's the only one smart enough to get behind cover and pick them off one by one. Or he'll just break their arms with his military training.

[JustRob]

Carl Johnson buried a guy in a toilet under concrete and left him to slowly die of suffocation, and also completely destroyed a building site, just because some of the workers whistled at his sis. He tied up a dude on top of his car and speeded the highway until the guy got a heart attack and had to be taken to the hospital. I think we've established he's a complete psychopath and totally ruthless, more so then Tommy Vercetti.

Sure CJ shows reluctancy when forced to kill Ryder or Big Smoke, but they were his childhood friends. Tommy didn't know Lance for that long and they were definitely not best buddies.

[lzw3]

Not sure how Claude would win. He has to stop walking every time he has to punch.