IMG

 
IMG
IMG   IMG
  Welcome to GTAForums! Be sure to check out the Grand Theft Auto V Forum.

You are not registered! (If you are, click here to login) Registering is fast, free and easy and allows you to instantly reply to any topic on GTAForums.
Why wait? Click here to register your own unique username and become part of the ever-growing community!


( Log In | Register | Revalidate Validation E-mail )
Quick Log-In:
  IMG
       
>
Forum Rules ...


Pages: (2) [1] 2   ( Go to first unread post ) Closed TopicStart new topicStart Poll

 [General] Ships in the City

 Is that a large vessel in your pocket?
 
Cerbera  
Posted: Saturday, Feb 3 2007, 10:23
Quote Post


Ben "Cerbera" Millard
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: Jun 22, 2002

en.gif

Member Award




There was talk of a modestly sized, single-deck car ferry last year. It would fit between railway pillars and access all parts of the coastline. GTASA has a car transporting COL surface and the handling can reduce wave movement. It would need suitable locations for loading and unloading. If we got all this together, it could add a dimension of gameplay which wasn't present in GTASA. smile.gif

Some examples of the thing we have in mind:Drivable ships are quite possible. For example, the Easter Bay Aircraft Carrier mod by NikT of the DRuG Crew:
user posted image
1024 x 768, 111kB.

I developed the handling and physics setup with them, so you can still use it as a runway:
user posted image
800 x 600, 115kB.

The main problems with ships are the COL limit and the draw distance. Walk to the ends of the Aircraft Carrier and it goes non-solid because you are so far away from its centre. Ships shorter than this with less interior detail would work fine.

What do other people thing about MISA featuring a large vessel of some sort?
Users WebsitePM
  Top
 

 
simzebu  
Posted: Saturday, Feb 3 2007, 16:29
Quote Post


Crackhead
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: May 7, 2006

XXXXX



Cool! I think that's a great idea!
PM
  Top
 

 
Cerbera  
Posted: Sunday, Feb 4 2007, 18:26
Quote Post


Ben "Cerbera" Millard
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: Jun 22, 2002

en.gif

Member Award




I've been talking to TRN about this idea over IRC. He's agreed to set aside Lot 17 on GTI as a ferry port, just in case anything comes of it. I've added real-world pics to the first message.

I'd like it to replace the Dozer or the dump truck, so at least one of the ramps would work. First thing is to do experiments to see if this will even work, though.

Some people I'm going to PM to see if they are interested:
  • Picolini
  • GTAuron
I don't think it's worth trying to make AI cars interact with it or even have it spawn on boat paths. It would just be for the player.

This post has been edited by Cerbera on Sunday, Feb 4 2007, 19:11
Users WebsitePM
  Top
 

 
Mark  
Posted: Sunday, Feb 4 2007, 21:59
Quote Post


Jesus hates you.
Group Icon
Group: Retired Staff
Joined: Aug 15, 2002

uk.gif

Member Award




In response to the PM, sure thing I'm game for making the port, probs base if off summin similar to the chain-link ferry near Swanage near Bournemouth.
PM
  Top
 

 
Cran.  
Posted: Monday, Feb 5 2007, 06:09
Quote Post


910 reprisent
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: Apr 20, 2004

au.gif

XXXXX



What about the Hoverspeed Seacat Ferry that goes from Dover to Calais? I think it would be a cool ferry

user posted image

Cool idea, i'd love a ferry in MI.
Users WebsitePMMSNYahoo
  Top
 

 
Blackadder.  
Posted: Monday, Feb 5 2007, 07:45
Quote Post


Luck. Runs. Out.
Group Icon
Group: Andolini Mafia Family
Joined: Jun 19, 2005

au.gif

XXXXX



Go for the Win icon14.gif

Cran: It would be cool too! smile.gif
Users WebsitePMMSNXbox Live
  Top
 

 
Diesel  
Posted: Monday, Feb 5 2007, 08:03
Quote Post


Getaway Driver
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: Jul 9, 2002

Member Award




QUOTE (Cerbera @ Feb 4 2007, 19:26)
I'd like it to replace the Dozer or the dump truck, so at least one of the ramps would work. First thing is to do experiments to see if this will even work, though.

What? You can't do that. At least, not last time I tried. Changing vehicle types causes all sorts of problems ingame.
Users WebsitePMMSNAOL
  Top
 

 
TRN4L  
Posted: Monday, Feb 5 2007, 08:05
Quote Post


Novus Ordo Seclorum
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: Jul 10, 2003

us.gif

Member Award




Diesel, i figured that would be the case. In my mind I'm thinking that (i think someone in IRC mentioned it) we could/should have two ferries, a passenger line and a freight/car line.
Users WebsitePMMSNAOLXbox Live
  Top
 

 
Cerbera  
Posted: Monday, Feb 5 2007, 09:36
Quote Post


Ben "Cerbera" Millard
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: Jun 22, 2002

en.gif

Member Award




Diesel: Picolini has done a lot of work with swapping vehicle types around, with some success. I'm not 100% sure if it's possible to do what we want, but it's worth experimenting with.

Cran: The ferry should fit through the railway bridge, even in high seas, so the player can take it everywhere. I don't think those big ones will fit. A downside is that big car ferries can't get close enough to a regular beach to drive straight onto them. With the small, flat car ferries you have a lot more freedom. smile.gif

TRN: Yeah that was me. tounge.gif I think a fancy passenger ferry as big as we can fit would be a nice in addition to a modestly sized, flat car ferry.

This post has been edited by Cerbera on Monday, Feb 5 2007, 09:40
Users WebsitePM
  Top
 

 
Picolini  
Posted: Sunday, Feb 11 2007, 18:31
Quote Post


ZOMG ROFL XD!!!!11
Group Icon
Group: BUSTED!
Joined: Dec 7, 2002

us.gif

XXXXX



Well crap, I'm a bit late on that PM Cerbera, sorry. For some reason I didn't get that "You have a new PM" pop up....

I do like the idea and I'll for sure help out with this, I've taken a month or so break from modding and now I'm ready to go, you guys got me at the right time wink.gif

As Cerbera said, I've done a lot of testing w/ replacing vehicles with different types. I don't recall how my car to boat experiments turned out, but I'll test some stuff out tonight or tomorrow.

Also, does this boat have the 5K-ish poly limit too? I don't think it should be a problem since the ferry's shape isn't too complex. Just want to make sure.

Also, what's the COL setting you were talking about Cerbera? The car carrying one... how do I set that for the boat?

Oh, and which boat should I replace for this?
PM
  Top
 

 
Mark  
Posted: Sunday, Feb 11 2007, 19:43
Quote Post


Jesus hates you.
Group Icon
Group: Retired Staff
Joined: Aug 15, 2002

uk.gif

Member Award




As the ferry is to be large, I say a bit more than 5k.

We also need to decide on a name/logo for the company too, so we can both use it.
PM
  Top
 

 
Picolini  
Posted: Monday, Feb 12 2007, 03:39
Quote Post


ZOMG ROFL XD!!!!11
Group Icon
Group: BUSTED!
Joined: Dec 7, 2002

us.gif

XXXXX



Ooops, smack me silly and call me a fairy tounge.gif
I asked what vehicle to replace, obviously either the dozer or the Packer. I don't know if either of those are taken but I think the Packer would be a better option. Don't know why, I just think so. I see Cerbera suggested the Dumper, I'll try that one out.

Now... a name for it. I'm guessing we want some funny pun type name...
Ferry in itself is funny, so probably build off of that.

- Merry Ferry Transportation
- Ferry Automotive Gurus (F.A.Gs wink.gif), could use any words with an A and G that make sense... best I could think of.

Those were the only two I can think of. I'm going to work on some test later on tonight and see what I can come up with. First I'll see if I can get the Packer to work as a boat. If not then the dozer... and any other vehicle with a movable part to see if it works. I'll let you guys know how it turns out.

This post has been edited by Picolini on Monday, Feb 12 2007, 05:08
PM
  Top
 

 
Cran.  
Posted: Monday, Feb 12 2007, 05:28
Quote Post


910 reprisent
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: Apr 20, 2004

au.gif

XXXXX



QUOTE (Cerbera @ Feb 5 2007, 20:06)
Cran: The ferry should fit through the railway bridge, even in high seas, so the player can take it everywhere. I don't think those big ones will fit. A downside is that big car ferries can't get close enough to a regular beach to drive straight onto them. With the small, flat car ferries you have a lot more freedom. smile.gif

Good point. You can't deny that Ferry is über cool, though! wink.gif
Users WebsitePMMSNYahoo
  Top
 

 
Picolini  
Posted: Monday, Feb 12 2007, 05:40
Quote Post


ZOMG ROFL XD!!!!11
Group Icon
Group: BUSTED!
Joined: Dec 7, 2002

us.gif

XXXXX



Bad news guys... I've tried everything I could think of and I can't get a ramp to work on a boat.

I tried
-Packer
-Dumper
-Dozer
-Andromada

Nothing works... sad.gif

I'll keep thinking but I just don't think it's gonna happen. It seems to be that animation properties hard coded to certain vehicles only work if they are assigned the correct vehicle type in the vehicles.ide. I even tried assigning dozer anims to the packer and that didn't change anything.

Too bad, this would have been a cool mod.
PM
  Top
 

 
Mark  
Posted: Monday, Feb 12 2007, 22:13
Quote Post


Jesus hates you.
Group Icon
Group: Retired Staff
Joined: Aug 15, 2002

uk.gif

Member Award




Ah crap...hmmph.

As far as I remember, can't you attach cars to vehicles using the .scm? I'm sure a design without a ramp can be achieved, if a little interesting to drive and load up.
PM
  Top
 

 
TRN4L  
Posted: Tuesday, Feb 13 2007, 02:42
Quote Post


Novus Ordo Seclorum
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: Jul 10, 2003

us.gif

Member Award




what about coding it so a "packer" spawns on top of a boat? and put the "packer" 's door dummy hidden while putting the boats dummy where you'd expect it... two vehicles, and we know there is a COL surface for carrying vehicles.
Users WebsitePMMSNAOLXbox Live
  Top
 

 
Diesel  
Posted: Tuesday, Feb 13 2007, 09:44
Quote Post


Getaway Driver
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: Jul 9, 2002

Member Award




QUOTE (TRN4L @ Feb 13 2007, 03:42)
what about coding it so a "packer" spawns on top of a boat? and put the "packer" 's door dummy hidden while putting the boats dummy where you'd expect it... two vehicles, and we know there is a COL surface for carrying vehicles.

What? I don't quite follow you here. It looks to me like you're suggesting you somehow manage to be in both the Packer and the boat at the same time? Huh? notify.gif
Users WebsitePMMSNAOL
  Top
 

 
Cran.  
Posted: Tuesday, Feb 13 2007, 10:35
Quote Post


910 reprisent
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: Apr 20, 2004

au.gif

XXXXX



Someone made a car air carrier a while pack. Search in Vehicles if interested..
Users WebsitePMMSNYahoo
  Top
 

 
Picolini  
Posted: Tuesday, Feb 13 2007, 15:12
Quote Post


ZOMG ROFL XD!!!!11
Group Icon
Group: BUSTED!
Joined: Dec 7, 2002

us.gif

XXXXX



TR4NL's idea actually might kinda work, but it'd take some heavy SCM coding I'm guessing.

If you could some how force the Packer to be morphed to a boat then I think his idea might work. What I would suggest is you first go to the packer entrance, then lower the misc_a part. Then load up your car. Run back to the Packer, cloase the misc_a part. Then you get in the actual boat to drive it. It'd be like two seperate sections for each function of the boat.

I just don't know if the scm is capable of making two vehicles be formed as one. Also the placement would be a bitch too.

I have doubts about that working though, I don't know how having a car permanently stuck to a boat would affect it's handling and stuff.

An easier alternative would just be to have the Ferry ends flush with the dock, like on these ones Balboa Island Ferry.
The only thing is I'd have to not model the openable gates at each end, which would mean the cars would have to either be parked at an angle so they would slide with heavy braking and acceleration, or that COL cerbera was talking about better be nice and sticky in heavy waves and driving forces.

Edit: And the car air carrier Cran. is talking about is the one made by pinky, I'm pretty sure. I think think some one else made one too, but if I remember right it wasn't that good.

Edit 2:
Well, whether or not we can get the ferry to work like we wish it would, I started modeling a ferry today. It's based off the Balboa Island Ferry I posted above, and some parts from the ones Cerbera posted.

user posted image
user posted image
user posted image

What do you guys think? 3,190 tri's.


This post has been edited by Picolini on Tuesday, Feb 13 2007, 21:08
PM
  Top
 

 
simzebu  
Posted: Tuesday, Feb 13 2007, 22:36
Quote Post


Crackhead
Group Icon
Group: Members
Joined: May 7, 2006

XXXXX



Oooh! It's Perfect!
PM
  Top
 

 

0 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)

0 Members:

Pages: (2) [1] 2 

Topic Options Closed TopicStart new topicStart Poll
Search topic for posted by (exact match)



 
IMG IMG